Sequence which has countably many convergent subsequences.

August 22, 2011

This post is about a question I just thought about that I thought had a pretty neat solution.  The values we consider below are all in the Reals.

 

So, we’re all familiar with sequences which have subsequences which converge to two different values; for example, take \{1,-1,1,-1,1,-1,\dots\} which has a subsequence converging to 1 and a subsequence converging to -1.  Similarly, we can construct a sequence containing subsequences converging to three different values in a similar way; for example: \{-1,0,1,-1,0,1, \dots\}.  Indeed, for any finite number, we can make a sequence containing subsequences converging to that number of different values.

 

The obvious next question is: can a sequence have subsequences which converge to a countable number of different values?  What about an uncountable number of different values?

 

For the former question, I thought of this solution.  First, enumerate your countable list of distinct values (think of the integers or the rationals, for example) as \{q_{1}, q_{2}, \dots\}.  To construct the sequence, we do the following:

  • Let a_{1} = 0.
  • Let a_{b} = 0 if b is not some positive power of a prime (for example, if b is 15, 21, 35, 100, etc.)
  • For a_{k} where k is a positive power of a prime, we do the following: If k = p_{i}^{r} for r\in {\mathbb N} and p_{i} is the i-th prime (so p_{1} = 2, p_{2} = 3, p_{3} = 5, and so on) then set a_{k} = q_{i} where q_{i} is the i-th element from your list above.

 

How does this actually work?  Let’s take a simple example.  Let’s let our countable set be the set of natural numbers.  This is easily ordered as \{1,2,3,4,5,\dots\} and so, for this example, q_{1} = 1, q_{2} = 2, q_{3} = 3, and so forth.  Our sequence is now:

\{a_{1}, a_{2}, a_{3}, a_{4}, a_{5}, a_{6}, a_{7}, a_{8}, a_{9}, a_{10},\dots\}

= \{a_{1}, a_{2}, a_{3}, a_{2^{2}}, a_{5}, a_{2\cdot 3}, a_{7}, a_{2^{3}}, a_{3^{2}}, a_{2\cdot 5}, \dots\}

= \{0, q_{1}, q_{2}, q_{1}, q_{3}, 0, q_{4}, q_{1}, q_{2}, 0, \dots\}

= \{0, 1, 2, 1, 3, 0, 4, 1, 2, 0, \dots\}

and if we kept going like this,

= \{0, 1, 2, 1, 3, 0, 4, 1, 2, 0, 5, 0, 6, 0, 0, 1, 7, 0, 8, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 3, 0,\dots\}

 

You kinda see the pattern going on here.  The 1 will appear infinitely many times, but the spaces between it grow exponentially.  Same for 2, 3, 4, and so on.  Thus, this sequence has the subsequence \{n, n, n, n, \dots\} for any n\in {\mathbb N} which obviously will converge to n.

 

Do you have another neat way to do this?  Encoding this in the primes was my first thought, but you never know!

 

As for uncountable, my guess is no.  Of course, thinking of the sequence as a SET, we would get the reals from the rationals which is uncountable, but as a SEQUENCE it is not so trivial I feel.  I don’t want to spend too much time thinking about this (as analysis is calling me!) but I’m sure the proof isn’t too crazy.

 

Edit: Of course, a nice example exists where a sequence has subsequences converging to an uncountable number of distinct point.  In fact, two nice examples exist, and both were provided to me by Brooke (as usual!).

 

Uncountable Example 1:

It was a bit difficult for me to see the first one, but after doing a nice little thought experiment everything became much clearer.  Here it is:

Let \{q_{1}, q_{2}, \dots\} be an enumeration of the rationals.  The claim is that there is actually a subsequence which converges to any real number.  Think about it for a minute.

Here’s a sketch for the proof.  Take your favorite real number.  Let’s start easy and just say we want a subsequence which converges to \pi.  Let a_{1} be the first element in our enumeration of the rationals above which is a distance less than 1 away from \pi; let’s say it’s q_{k}.  Now let a_{2} be the first element in our enumeration which is after q_{k} and which is a distance less than \frac{1}{2} away from \pi

After that, you just keep picking the "next" element from the list that’s \frac{1}{2^{n}} away from \pi.  There must be one due to the density of the rationals in the reals (or, assume not and see what happens!).  We end up with \{a_{1}, a_{2}, \dots\} as a subsequence of our enumeration of the rationals which converges to \pi.  Obviously, replacing \pi with any other real number works exactly the same.

 

Uncountable example 2:

This was one that Brooke presented to me that I liked quite a bit since it’s really easy to state.  Here’s the sequence (broken up by lines for clarity):

 

0.0\,,\, 0.1\,,\, 0.2\,,\, \dots\,,\, 0.9,

0.00\,,\, 0.01\,,\, 0.02\,,\, \dots\,, \,0.09\,,\, 0.10\,,\, 0.11\,,\, \dots\,,\, 0.99\,,

0.000\,,\, 0.001\,,\, 0.002\,,\, \dots\,,\, 0.999\,, \dots

 

This converges to any real number in [0,1].  To see this is easy: decimal expand your chosen real number and pick the element "from each line" (as I’ve written it above) which is closest to it.  They’ll be at most 10^{-j} away (for some suitable j depending on the line you’re on) and thus a subsequence exists which converges to whatever element you picked.

Advertisements

3 Responses to “Sequence which has countably many convergent subsequences.”

  1. CodeLabMaster said

    I don’t know if I would consider it a neat way to get a sequence that has a countable number of convergent sub-sequences, but it’s certainly easy: {1,1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,…}.

  2. ただ あなたの記事のようにあると言う驚くべき。 | 単にあなたのポストで鮮明透明性がある 壮大な優れたと私はでき |この主題の専門家あなたがしているあなたがあると仮定します。 まあ今後のポストに| 更新日まで保つために| | フィードRSSフィード私はあなたをつかむためにあなたの許可を持つましょう許可。おかげで百万と継続 報酬仕事。
    国内即発 人気急上昇 http://firststepsolutions.in

  3. 、あなたのための著者あなたが探している場合は私に知らせてください。 投稿と私は|あなたはいくつかの本当に良い素晴らしいを持っている​​信じる私は良い資産になります。バック鉱山へのリンクと引き換えにあなたのブログのための いくつかを書くことがあなたがこれまで負荷オフのいくつかを取りたい場合は、私が と思います。興味があれば| 電子メールを電子メール 爆発を送信してください。 よろしく!
    送料無料激安通販通販 国内即発 http://ribamarnazare.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: